Greetings, fellow history fans and coin collectors! We hope you're having a good time collecting coins. However, have you ever considered the background of an old penny? Here in this draft we will understand the 1905 Indian Head Penny, one of the most recognizable coins in America.
It is a small time capsule, a piece of American history that you can grasp in your palm, and it is more than just a penny. This currency, which was in circulation for many years, saw important past events and developed into a representation of the character of the country. There is an appealing charm to the 1905 Indian Head Penny, regardless of how long you have been collecting coins. Let's investigate what makes this tiny copper coin so unique.
The Indian Head penny isn’t just old money—it’s a piece of American history. Made from 1859 to 1909, it was designed by James Barton Longacre. The front shows Lady Liberty wearing a Native American headdress, symbolizing American spirit. The back has a wreath and a Union shield, showing strength and unity.
Although many were produced, their worth varies according to their state. Shiny, well-kept coins are worth more. Each year has small differences, which makes collecting them fun and interesting.
You might think it’s just a penny, but the 1905 Indian Head Penny is a favorite for collectors. It connects us to a time of big change in early 1900s America. Many were made, so it's easy to start collecting with this coin. Its value depends on how rare and well-kept it is. Finding one in great shape or with a mistake makes it feel like a real treasure. That mix of history, ease, and excitement keeps collectors interested.
We have to look at the entire Indian Head series and its history, including the quantity produced and the grading system, in order to fully understand this coin.
In the 1800s, pennies were big—about the size of a modern half-dollar. As copper got expensive, the U.S. Mint switched to smaller coins. The first small penny was the Flying Eagle Cent (1857–1858), made with copper and nickel. It was hard to mint, so in 1859, the Indian Head Cent was created. It was lighter, cheaper, and easier to use, and it stayed popular for 50 years.
By 1905, the coin was made of 95% copper and 5% tin and zinc (bronze)—a mix used from 1864 to 1909.
James Longacre was the U.S. Mint’s head engraver from 1844 to 1869. He also designed other coins like the Flying Eagle and Shield Nickel.
Even though it's called the “Indian Head” penny, it doesn’t show a real Native American. Longacre used Lady Liberty and added a feathered headdress to make it feel more “American.”
Some believe he used his daughter Sarah as the model, but he said he was inspired by a statue called “Crouching Venus” in a Philadelphia museum.
Front (obverse):
The obverse side of the 1905 Indian Head Penny features Lady Liberty facing left, wearing a detailed feathered headdress with the word “LIBERTY” inscribed on the band. Just below her image is the date “1905,” and encircling the top of the coin are the words “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.”
Back (reverse):
On the reverse, an oak wreath surrounds the denomination “ONE CENT.” At the top of the wreath sits a Union shield, while the bottom is adorned with three arrows tied together with a ribbon. These artistic elements come together to form a classic and historically rich design.
In 1905, Theodore Roosevelt was president. America was booming with new ideas and inventions. The first Yellow Pages came out, and Roosevelt won the Nobel Peace Prize.
People earned about 10 cents an hour, so a penny had real value. The 1905 Indian Head Penny was a part of daily life for many.
Collectors love the Indian Head penny for more than just its age. The front, with Lady Liberty in a Native headdress, broke from European-style coin art. It reflected American identity. The back—with its wreath, shield, arrows, and ribbon—stood for unity, strength, and peace.
Some 1905 pennies have minting errors, like:
Clipped planchet (part of the coin is missing)
Doubled die obverse (double image)
These rare mistakes can make a coin more valuable.
Even though many were made, coins in mint condition (shiny and well-kept) are worth more—especially if they still have a red or red-brown color.
In general, coin value depends on grade (condition).
Worn coins: a few dollars
Perfect coins: can be worth hundreds or thousands
Knowing the basic specs can help you identify and appreciate your 1905 Indian Head Penny.
Here are the key details for the 1905 Indian Head Penny:
Composition: 95% Copper, 5% Tin and Zinc (this mix is called bronze)
Weight: 3.11 grams
Diameter: 19 millimeters (or 19.05mm, which is about 0.75 inches)
Edge: Plain (meaning it's smooth, not ridged like a dime or quarter)
"Mintage" means how many coins were produced.
All 1905 Indian Head Pennies were made at the Philadelphia Mint, which didn’t put a mint mark on pennies back then.
80,717,011 coins were made for everyday use.
This was the 5th highest mintage in the Indian Head series.
That’s why 1905 pennies are still easy to find, especially worn ones.
Some sources say only 27 million were made, but 81 million is the most accepted number.
Only 2,152 proof coins were made.
These were specially made for collectors, using polished dies and blanks.
They look shinier and have sharper details, making them much rarer and more valuable.
Adding both types together, 80,719,163 1905 Indian Head Pennies were produced.
The value of a 1905 Indian Head Penny depends mostly on its condition, or what collectors call its "grade." Coins in better shape are worth more, while worn ones are worth less. Proof coins, which were made specially for collectors, can be much more valuable. Since every coin is different, prices can vary a lot based on how well it was preserved and how rare it is.
The value of a 1905 Indian Head Penny is heavily influenced by its condition, or "grade." Coins that look almost new, like Uncirculated ones, are worth much more than those that are worn down. The original copper color is also important.
Uncirculated coins may still have some bright red luster, while circulated ones will have a brown (BN) or red-brown (RB) mix, with the full red (RD) coins being the most valuable. High-grade coins, especially those with full red color, are rare and worth a lot.
A coin’s eye appeal—how nice it looks—also matters; sharp details and smooth surfaces make a coin more attractive. Proof coins, made for collectors, are much rarer and more valuable than regular coins. Special versions or coins with minting errors can also be worth more. Finally, like all collectibles, the value can change depending on how much demand there is from collectors.
Coin grading can be tricky, but here’s a simple way to understand it. Coins are graded from 1 (Poor) to 70 (Perfect). For circulated coins (used ones):
Good (G-4) means it’s very worn, but the major designs are still faintly visible.
Fine (F-12) means it’s moderately worn, but more details can be seen.
Extremely Fine (XF-40) shows light wear with fine and smaller details.
About Uncirculated (AU-50) looks almost new, with just a tiny trace of wear.
For Uncirculated coins (no wear):
MS-60 to MS-62 means no wear but might have marks or dull luster.
MS-63 to MS-64 is called "Choice Uncirculated" with better luster and fewer marks.
MS-65 to MS-67 are highly valued for great luster, strong strike, and tiny marks.
Proof coins are graded similarly (PR-60 to PR-70) with extra focus on their shiny, reflective surfaces. Trusted grading companies like PCGS and NGC assess and grade coins, then seal the coins in secured holders to ensure buyers and sellers can trust the coin's value.
The BN, RB, and RD labels are very important for copper coins like the 1905 Indian Head Penny, especially the uncirculated ones. Copper changes over time and loses its bright red shine, turning brown.
BN (Brown) coins have less than 5-10% of their original red color. Most circulated coins and many uncirculated ones that weren’t stored well are in this category.
RB (Red-Brown) coins show a brown and red mix, with around 10-90% red. These still have some of their original shine and look like new.
RD (Red) coins keep 90-95% of their original bright red color. They were likely stored very carefully, in airtight containers or rolls.
An RD coin, even with the same grade as a BN coin, can be worth much more because the red color shows excellent preservation.
Let’s talk numbers! The 1905 Indian Head Penny value can vary and depends on the market. Always verify the latest price guides or take the advice of expert dealers for the most accurate information. Stack’s Bowers, a well-known auction house, has sold many valuable Indian Head pennies, showing their importance and credibility in the coin market.
Good-4 (G-4): $2 - $3
Fine-12 (F-12): $5 - $7
Extremely Fine-40 (XF-40): $10 - $16
About Uncirculated-50 (AU-50): $20 - $36
1905 Indian Head Penny (Business Strike)
| Grade | Approx. Value (BN) | Approx. Value (RB) | Approx. Value (RD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| MS-60 | $40 - $50 | $55 - $60 | $60 - $75 |
| MS-63 | $60 - $90 | $75 - $135 | $160 - $165 |
| MS-65 | $140 - $200 | $200 - $250 | $650 - $675 |
| MS-66 | $375 - $475 | $850 | $1,600 - $1,700 |
| MS-67 | Scarce (BN/RB) | Scarce (BN/RB) | $17,000+ |
Proof 1905 Indian Head Penny (No Mint Mark - Philadelphia)
| Grade | Approx. Value (BN) | Approx. Value (RB) | Approx. Value (RD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| PR-63 | $275 - $285 | $350 | $350 |
| PR-65 | $650 | $625 | $1,150 |
| PR-67 | $3,000+ | $5,150+ | $8,000 - $11,750+ |
Some rare 1905 Indian Head Pennies have sold for impressive amounts at auction. For example, an MS-67 Red business strike sold for $19,975 in April 2013, and a Proof PR-67 Red went for $11,750 in March 2014. This shows that while many 1905 Indian Head pennies are affordable, high-quality ones are the primary choice of collectors.
For collectors, finding unusual 1905 Indian Head Pennies is similar to finding a most valued object. Some errors and varieties are visible without magnification, adding value. A variety is a minor design change due to die modifications, like a repunched date. A mint error occurs at the time of the minting procedure, such as an off-center strike or a coin struck on the wrong planchet.
Repunched Date (RPD): Slightly offset numbers in the date.
Doubled Die Obverse (DDO): Doubling in parts of the obverse design.
Struck on Wrong Planchet: A penny design struck on a gold planchet.
Off-Center Strike: Part of the design is missing.
Double Strike: The coin struck twice.
Clipped Planchet: A missing piece from the planchet.
Die Breaks (Cuds) and Strike-Throughs: Flaws from damaged dies or debris.
Learn about grading and keep an eye on market values when collecting. Online auctions, coin shows, local coin stores, and specialized online platforms and websites are all excellent places to buy. Look for coins with good luster, firm striking, and no issues. Coins certified by the PCGS or NGC are more reliable.
Watch for signs of counterfeiting or alteration, like weak details, odd surface textures, and incorrect weight. If you're not sure, check the coin against real ones and think about having it verified.
To protect your coin, hold it carefully by the edges and keep it in safe, non-damaging holders or plastic cases. Don’t clean your coin, as it can harm the surface. Keep your collection in a cool, dry place to stop it from wearing down.
The 1905 Indian Head Penny gives us a glimpse into early 1900s America. Its value can go from just a few dollars to thousands, based on things like its color, condition, and how rare it is. Whether you're new or experienced in collecting, this coin is a special part of coin history.
Happy Collecting!
Affiliations
Copyright BOLD Precious Metals 2025
